Seiko SARG007 and Hamilton Khaki Field H70555533

I acquired the Hamilton Khaki Field Automatic H70555533 recently and thought it would be nice to do a quick comparison with the Seiko SARG007 which I already have in my collection. Both of these watches are military inspired and have quite a bit of similarities between them.

The Seiko SARG007 is a discontinued model under the Mechanical line. It is a Japan domestic model priced at JPY45,000 excluding tax (about SGD561.00). This watch is powered by the Seiko 6R15 movement with beat rate of 21,600bph and a power reserve of 50 hours. It has a diameter of 41mm excluding crown.

The Hamilton Khaki H70555533 is a current model (as at June 2017) under the Hamilton Khaki Field collection. It is priced at SGD720 inclusive of GST. The price excluding GST (for better comparison with the SARG007) is SGD672.00. This model of Hamilton Khaki Field was previously powered by ETA 2824. This piece I have is the latest version which is fitted with the Hamilton H10 movement. This movement is based on the ETA 2824 but has its beat rate reduced from 28,800bph to 21,600bph and power reserved increased to 80 hours. This watch comes in three sizes – 38mm, 42mm and 44mm excluding crown. Mine is a 42mm.

I always start by looking at the dial when it comes to military inspired watches because this is the part that determines whether I like the watch or not. Both the Seiko and Hamilton have the type of dial layout that I like. They have full hour numerals except for ‘3’ which is ‘eaten’ by the date window. These hour numerals are the right size that I prefer and next to each of them is a 24 hour marking in smaller size. On the Seiko, the ’15’ marking is omitted while on the Hamilton, the ’15’ marking is shifted inwards which is acceptable I guess.

The numerals on the Hamilton are printed in white whereas those of the Seiko are slightly yellowish.

Both watches have similar looking hour and minute hands except the Hamilton has silver coloured outline while the Seiko has white outline. The second hand on the Seiko is mainly white while the Hamilton is again silver. However, it has a red tip and reaches all the way to the edge of the dial.

Both watches do not have anti-reflective coating on their crystals but I see more reflections on the Hamilton than the Seiko. This is due to the curved crystal as well as the dial. The Seiko has a matte black dial and always appear so regardless of which angle you look at it. The Hamilton dial on the other hand appears to be greyish from certain angle. It also has textures on the part where the hour numerals are printed.

The Seiko is the thicker watch of the two and part of its thickness comes from the taller bezel which is needed to accommodate the inner rotating bezel which can be rotated by the crown at 4 o’clock.

The Hamilton has a relatively flat bezel as you can see in the picture below.

The Seiko has mostly brushed finishing on the front except for a polished stripe on both sides of the case. The Hamilton has brushed finishing everywhere except the bezel which is polished.

When you turn them around, you will see that the Seiko has polished finishing and the Hamilton has brush finishing. Both watches are water resistant to 100 metres. They do not come with screw down crown.

Performance wise, I notice that the Hamilton is very accurate. I suppose every piece of H10 movement by Hamilton is well regulated before leaving the factory. I briefly tested the Seiko and Hamilton on a timegrapher and it shows that the Hamilton is pretty accurate.

Conclusion:
The Seiko SARG007 and Hamilton Khaki Field share many similarities including the utilitarian look of many military inspired watches. Based on design alone, I would prefer the Hamilton because it has the classic look of a military styled watch and most importantly, it does not have the inner compass bezel and hence the additional crown at 4 o’clock.

The Hamilton though is not the most hardcore military inspired watch out there due to its polished bezel, partially textured dial and silver outline on the hands. Besides being a watch for casual events, it can also be used as a dress watch.

Lastly, if you know of any nice military inspired watches, please feel free to put them in the comments below.

_________________________________________________

Hamilton Khaki Field H70555533 was purchased at Watches of Switzerland (Vivo City)
Seiko SARG007 is a discontinued model that is no longer available.

 

Advertisements

3 thoughts on “Seiko SARG007 and Hamilton Khaki Field H70555533

  1. I have purchased both of these watches over the years for my son. I like both pieces and would be hard pressed th choose a favorite.

  2. I want to thank you for your thoughtful and comprehensive watch reviews. I really enjoy everything you write about. Well done!

  3. Shifting the 15 inwards on the Hamilton totally kills it for me. I just can’t get over it. It would be one of my dream watches otherwise; I’m sure its movement would give years of accurate service.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s